Warhorse Simulations

Automated Card Tracking System: Home

Generic Module: MM/MS ATR Game 4 Journal

Number of entries per page:
  Sort order:
Most recent entries first
Oldest entries first

Filter on: (filter will search Player, Title, and Entry)

View elapsed game time

View game card play report

Next 100 entries

Entry # Time Turn Player Title Entry
144 2/23/2021 9:05:00 AM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Change of plan. Italian Navy stayed home - no SR attempt. Will send you logfile wrapping up turn.
143 2/22/2021 9:29:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Sending you logfile with attempted Italian SR to Libya. Please note interception if you wish it.
142 2/22/2021 6:21:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message LL27
141 2/22/2021 5:33:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Oops - that's MM26.
140 2/22/2021 5:33:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Got it. Please vacate M26 and let me know retreat hex. Thx.
139 2/22/2021 3:47:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message Med attrition remove two French 1x in Tunisia
138 2/21/2021 9:01:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message 2C/1 hex. Please specify counters.
137 2/21/2021 9:00:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

1


Message from Mike Scott:
Attrition in MEd 11-20 column
136 2/21/2021 8:57:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message CA1 followed by exchange. 1 German armor an 1 air factor kia.
135 2/21/2021 8:54:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

4
4
2
2


Message from Mike Scott:
3 exploiting armor and 4 air on T20. 16-8, 2-1.
134 2/21/2021 8:52:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Exchange. Air factors kia.
133 2/21/2021 8:51:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

1
5
4
2


Message from Mike Scott:
Exploiting armor and 2 air factors on Q23. 6-2, 3-1.
132 2/21/2021 8:48:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Result D.

131 2/21/2021 8:47:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

5
3
4
5


Message from Mike Scott:
3 Exploiting armor units and 4 air factors on N24. 16-8, 2-1.
130 2/21/2021 8:45:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

3


Message from Mike Scott:
Interception result tied, so this roll is losses for both.
129 2/21/2021 8:44:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

2
3


Message from Mike Scott:
5 Germans from Essen intercept French DAS (-1). German roll first as always.
128 2/21/2021 8:35:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Okay, supply to Linya disrupted.
127 2/21/2021 7:59:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message made
126 2/21/2021 7:58:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

4


Message from Michael Mitchell:
9 Hexes
125 2/21/2021 7:03:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message I assume you will roll for the success of your French fleet interception of supply. Closest point of intercept looks like 9 hexes.
124 2/21/2021 7:01:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Okay, sorry I missed that DAS. Germans will intercept that.
123 2/21/2021 6:01:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message Message 100 for DAS

Frence Air to the attacked hex N24
122 2/21/2021 5:59:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message French fleet Tunis will intercept in Tobruk
121 2/21/2021 5:15:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Still need your DAS decision please, so I can finish my awesome turn!
120 2/21/2021 5:14:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Thanks, good perspective. As I said last game, sometimes your (bad) number comes up, and you suck it up.
119 2/21/2021 5:07:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message At one convention when I was GM in early 1990s playing 3R4 One of the 16 players rolled a 4-6 combination on Warsaw and lost 36 BRP like that and another 15 BRPs coming up for another East Front offensive = 51 BRP!
He was hot!
118 2/21/2021 4:56:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message yes I sent the Q&A about this rule in because I had several people misread latching on the EX as if it were a CA EX instead of an attacker exchange and totally ignoring the requirement to lost equal to the defenders modified strength. In my past days I only played 3R4 and A3R for about 8 years, sent in lots of Q&A to get to 3R4 as the earlier versions were all but unplayable with large gaps in rules.
117 2/21/2021 4:51:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message I was one of the ones who wanted the change under the 3R4 rules a 4-6 was a total wipe out. being as you were attacking at 4 times the defenders strength to begin with a total elimination was too much especially as it usually involved air support and armor , this is still a kick in the teeth but you save half your force and can take the loses from the cheapest units.
116 2/21/2021 12:17:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Sea supply to Libya from Brindisi down coast of Greece to Crete, then south to Tobruk.
115 2/21/2021 11:41:00 AM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Latest logfile does not show additional infantry loss but I will send that in next update.
114 2/21/2021 11:40:00 AM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Alright I guess I went a bridge too far on the exploitation. Okay, much simpler now. 3 armor units exploit into N25 and remain there. Will send corrected logfile.
113 2/21/2021 11:26:00 AM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message I find the "modified" thing in the rule to be unclear and subject to interpretation. So did whomever wrote the Qs and As. I found a Q&A in that file that takes the same position you do. So I will remove another infantry. Implying I should be happy I did not lose everything is a bit dubious. That result is a 3% probability event. And for a key roll like that one it is an utter disaster. Next to that consequence, you are right that 3 infantry factors are nothing.
112 2/21/2021 10:03:00 AM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message I still do mot understand your EXPLOITATION you marked the two armor which were involved in the attack on Brussels as exploiting the unit in L25 is 3 hexes away from another exploiting unit but the limit is two?
111 2/21/2021 10:00:00 AM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message The D result in Brussels was on a counterattack with the Belgian strength at 3, not doubled. All DMs are disregarded. I lose 3 factors.

Yes and normally on a D result ALL the defenders would be removed but in this case you only remove as many as the MODIFEID strength of the original defender. MY Modified strength was 6. This is way better than losing all your attackers.
110 2/21/2021 9:51:00 AM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message Sea supply in Med ?
109 2/21/2021 7:24:00 AM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Result D.
108 2/21/2021 7:24:00 AM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

6
6
5
6


Message from Mike Scott:
Attack on The Hague. 9-4, 2-1.
107 2/21/2021 7:23:00 AM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message I forgot to finish the attack on The Hague, upon which the para was to drop. Would appreciate your forbearance in allowing me to resolve that now.
106 2/20/2021 11:31:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message You are right about the location of the exploit counter. I put it on the wrong hex. Resolved the overrun, fixed the exploit marker, and added support air to one potential exploit attack that I mistakenly left off. NOW hopefully okay. Sending new logfile now.
105 2/20/2021 11:25:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message The D result in Brussels was on a counterattack with the Belgian strength at 3, not doubled. All DMs are disregarded. I lose 3 factors.
104 2/20/2021 11:23:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message 15.44 you 4-6 loss results vs. Brussels are limited to the defenders modified defense which in this case was 6.
103 2/20/2021 11:17:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message why is the a exploit marker on brussels// you can not use that to trace you 2 hex chain?
102 2/20/2021 11:16:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message I think you failed attack vs Brussels cost you a full exchange ?
101 2/20/2021 10:47:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message
100 2/20/2021 10:46:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message I do not undersand you overun it appears that you moved 3 spaces away from you breaktru and do not have the required two hex chain?

Frence Air to the attacked hex N24
99 2/20/2021 10:40:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message How can you do overruns during combat ?
98 2/20/2021 10:38:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message first things first lets resolve Med sea supply after i see that you air have flown.
97 2/20/2021 10:37:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message Overrun takes place during movement so I can assign air after you overrun . you are sort of getting ahead and mixing up sequences? unless this is exploitation overrun.

96 2/20/2021 10:34:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message D elim. Please consult logfile just sent and let me know about DAS. Logfile does not show result of overrun.
95 2/20/2021 10:33:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

3


Message from Mike Scott:
Overrun at L25. 6-1.
94 2/20/2021 10:27:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message Supply in med ? trace route i will probably intercept
93 2/20/2021 9:38:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message CA1, CA, D = D elim.
92 2/20/2021 9:37:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

4
2
6
4


Message from Mike Scott:
T22 on T21. 7-3, 2-1.
91 2/20/2021 9:35:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Defender elim.
90 2/20/2021 9:35:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

6
5
4
1


Message from Mike Scott:
Okay plan B. 2 adjoining infantry and 1 armor on N25. 10-2, 5-1.
89 2/20/2021 9:27:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message I just got the horror story 2-1 result. I lose 3 factors, Belgians none.
88 2/20/2021 9:23:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 5

4
6
5
1
1


Message from Mike Scott:
Adjoining units on Brussels. 13-6, 2-1.
87 2/20/2021 9:21:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message I assume no DAS since you did not say, so will proceed.
86 2/20/2021 9:21:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Modified DR6. 2 subs kia, others go back to port.
85 2/20/2021 9:19:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

4
3


Message from Mike Scott:
5 Italian air attempt to smite the subs. (-1)
84 2/20/2021 5:25:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

5


Message from Michael Mitchell:
need 1-5
83 2/20/2021 5:25:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message 5 SUBS intercept them
82 2/20/2021 5:23:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Same outcome, Belgians kia no German loss.
81 2/20/2021 5:22:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

6
1


Message from Mike Scott:
1 German air against 1 Belgian air -2.
80 2/20/2021 5:22:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Dutch kia, no German loss.
79 2/20/2021 5:21:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

5
6


Message from Mike Scott:
Counterair Netherlands. 1 German, 1 Dutch -2. German roll always first.
78 2/20/2021 5:20:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Sent you Axis Spring 40 logfile Part 1. Italy DoW, German offensive in west. You have decision points on intercepting Italian base change in Med, and DAS anywhere you feel like sending it. While I await your decisions, I will resolve counterairs against minors.
77 2/19/2021 4:01:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message wimps

76 2/19/2021 3:50:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Denmark caves to legitimate German demands
75 2/19/2021 3:49:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

3


Message from Mike Scott:
Diplo roll for Denmark
74 2/19/2021 3:31:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message NO DP Denmark
73 2/19/2021 3:09:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Please specify if you have DPs in Denmark and please send me a setup for Belgium.
72 2/19/2021 3:08:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Down to business. Germany declares war on Benelux, Netherlands, and Denmark.
71 2/19/2021 3:08:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Italy DP in Benelux.
70 2/19/2021 2:52:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message was that a German DP in Benelux?
69 2/19/2021 2:51:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message no effect
68 2/19/2021 2:50:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

3


Message from Michael Mitchell:

67 2/19/2021 2:50:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Axis also have 1 DP in Belgium. So net change is zero.
Only DR6 has any impact. Your roll unless you want me to do it.
66 2/19/2021 2:47:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Sorry, I sent you my "no DPs" message in email not ACTS.
65 2/19/2021 1:31:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message France names Benelux 1 DP
64 2/19/2021 12:29:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message Axis name and DP?
63 2/16/2021 3:34:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message you listed them Russia

90 +15 =10 + 30% 4 = 116
British 125 -12 SW = 113
French 41 @ 30% =92
62 2/16/2021 3:27:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message you surprised me with no winter action what is the BRP count?
61 2/16/2021 3:20:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message I will send you logfile with DP allocations. Germans have 5, Italians 2. By my count British have 4, French 2, Russians 4.
60 2/16/2021 3:18:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Germans: 170 BRP, less 17 for SW. Total 153.

Italians: 30 BRP left over at 20% = 6 added to 75 = 81 total.
59 2/16/2021 3:14:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Love that movement trail! :-)

I will remove the replacement next to France.

No raiders this turn, and no SW. So guess we are on to YSS.
58 2/16/2021 2:57:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message Remove a SP
57 2/16/2021 2:57:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

2


Message from Michael Mitchell:
Attritions all

West 1-10 column
56 2/14/2021 1:36:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message US/Axis tensions at 4 from last turn, which did not include Russian transgressions in Poland and Baltic States. So after this turn, we have 4 + 2 for winter turn - 2 for Russian aggression = 4.
55 2/14/2021 12:58:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message No effect.
54 2/14/2021 12:57:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

6


Message from Mike Scott:
Winter 39 attrition in west, 11-20 column.
53 2/14/2021 7:20:00 AM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message No problem. Had you rolled a 6, I would have been totally good with your having done the roll! :-)
52 2/13/2021 2:54:00 PM Turn 2 Michael Mitchell Message In this game the rolls are made by the attacker unlike other games sorry fir the confusion,
51 2/13/2021 2:16:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message No effect in Belgium either. On to Axis winter 39 turn.
50 2/13/2021 2:16:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

3


Message from Mike Scott:
Belgium diplo roll Winter 39
49 2/13/2021 2:15:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message Okay now I see you are calling on Belgium and want me to roll on your behalf. Will do. Axis also have 1 DP in Belgium so change is zero.
48 2/13/2021 2:14:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message No effect in Italy.
47 2/13/2021 2:14:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

4


Message from Mike Scott:
59.53 states that die is rolled by player who named the target. So here comes Italy (+1).
46 2/13/2021 2:13:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message I also assume no Russian roll since none stated.
45 2/13/2021 2:10:00 PM Turn 2 Mike Scott Message I'm confused about what you just sent me. Were you doing my DP roll for Italy? Think that is mine to roll.

And you said you have 1 DP in Belgium. Does that mean you are rolling for Belgium? If so, you need me to reveal Axis DPs there, right?

Next 100 entries

Copyright 2005 Warhorse Simulations