Warhorse Simulations

Automated Card Tracking System: Home

Generic Module: DG vs SA Journal

Number of entries per page:
  Sort order:
Most recent entries first
Oldest entries first

Filter on: (filter will search Player, Title, and Entry)

View elapsed game time

View game card play report

Next 100 entries

Entry # Time Turn Player Title Entry
85 4/19/2021 7:37:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message In any case, it appears as though ownership of the Advantage will make no difference in this game which I now estimate as a German victory with at least 90% likelihood.
84 4/19/2021 7:34:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

3
2
5
5


Message from Allies:
Yes, well ... no game is perfect. As we've discussed previously you see the entire concept of the Advantage as bogus and in that you are not alone. I, on the other hand, see it as a strength and the source of some of the game's most difficult player decisions.

7A2:

ETF vs 10 (192) @ 8:4
83 4/19/2021 7:00:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

2


Message from Germans:
My major one thing about this game that I don't like is what just happened. You getting the Advantage back when the Germans have no control (well, any sane German!) because you eliminated 3 CAs!!!! The rules should have said whenever 3 Non-CA units are eliminated!!!!!

Enough with my whining!!!!!

7G2
33: Bridge demo attempt - 33-31 +2
82 4/18/2021 7:32:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Edit Advantage Allies: from to X
Germans: from X to
81 4/18/2021 7:31:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message 7A1a, Part 4:

30: 16, 18, 115, 116 vs 30 supported by 1 & 29 Art @ 14:4 - OVR

16 & 116 to 19 supported by 1 & 29 Art @ 10:3 - OVR

Advantage regained by trifecta
18 & 115 to 31 supported by 1 & 29 Art @ 10:3 - OVR
80 4/18/2021 7:31:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

3
6
3
5


Message from Allies:
7A1a, Part 3:

30: 16, 18, 115, 116 vs 30 supported by 1 & 29 Art @ 14:4 - OVR

16 & 116 to 19 supported by 1 & 29 Art @ 10:3 - OVR
18 & 115 to 31 supported by 1 & 29 Art @ 10:3 -
79 4/18/2021 7:29:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

5
4
1
3


Message from Allies:
7A1a, Part 2:

30: 16, 18, 115, 116 vs 30 supported by 1 & 29 Art @ 14:4 - OVR

16 & 116 to 19 supported by 1 & 29 Art @ 10:3
78 4/18/2021 7:28:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

2
1
4
2


Message from Allies:
7A1a:

30: 16, 18, 115, 116 vs 30 supported by 1 & 29 Art @ 14:4
77 4/18/2021 6:57:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message Bridge down
76 4/18/2021 6:57:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

2


Message from Germans:
7G1A
29: Bridge demo attempt - 29-30 +5
75 4/17/2021 11:34:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message 352 Art spent
74 4/17/2021 11:34:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

1
4
3
3


Message from Allies:
7A1:

IX AF vs 32 @ 5:1
73 4/17/2021 8:06:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message "Sometimes its hard to see the values of the pieces, that's why I missed up with 729,739"

I agree - especially when I forget my glasses. But what made this strange was that you cited the correct unit ID for Area 58 AND that the unit came from Area 58. It didn't matter as it turned out, but it could have if you got a WC and opted to move five units from 58 - with one already used.
72 4/17/2021 7:10:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message 7G Dawn

1: CA 731
6: 744
5: 125
B: SS x8
C: Lehr X6
10: 21Pz/22,Flak,192,Art 711/Art
16: 736
14: 21Pz/PAK
23: 84 Corp Art
21: 915
20: 726
29: 916
19: CA
30: CA D1
31: CA
32: 352/Art
33: 914 32 Flak
36: 30
43: 752
44: 6FS 100PzRP
50: CA
46: 91/Pak,Art 921
49: 1057
47: 243/922,Art CA
54: 3x Flaks 709/729,Art
52: 1058 709/739,919 CA
58: 101NW 920 2x CA
56,57,60 - CAs

Sometimes its hard to see the values of the pieces, that's why I missed up with 729,739

7G1
AOK7 & 919 to 50
71 4/16/2021 9:39:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message FYI See message 44. You had moved 739 earlier to 52. It makes no difference now since 729 can move to 54 but for the record you should switch the two units.
70 4/16/2021 9:36:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message 6A Regroup:

50-51: 101 x3
18-17: 8 Arm, 50 x4
17-18: Ca Arm, 7 & 8 - all spent
J-17: Ca Art

A7 Dawn:

49: 507 spent, 508
50: 82 x2
51; 4/22, 101 x3; 4 D1 x2
30: nine
18: 56X, Ca 7 & 8 & Arm - all spent
17: Ca Art, Ca9, 8 Arm, 50 x4
8: seven
7: 6/3 spent; 6/5 & 6

bridges: 50 x3, 16/18
X Bridges: 20/18 +1, 20/17
69 4/16/2021 7:15:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message 6G Regroup

1-6: 744
6-5: 125
5-10: 21Pz/Art,22 711/Art
10-16: 736
16-10 21Pz/Flak
16-14: 21Pz/PAK
20-21: 915
29-20 726
29-32: 352/Art
29-28: 1 Flak
27-23: 84 Corp Art
31-33: 32 Flak 914
41-43: 752
41-36: 30
45-44: 100 PzRP
47-46: 921
48-46: 91/Pak,Art
56-47: 243/Art,922
58-54: 709/Art,739 - 3 Flak units
57-58: 101NW 920

68 4/15/2021 6:33:00 PM Turn 1 Allies Edit Supplies Allies: from 0 to 8
Germans: from 2 to 2
67 4/15/2021 6:33:00 PM Turn 1 Allies Message A6 Refit:

51: 4/22, 101 x3 - Save 1
30: nine fresh
18: 56X Spent; 8 Arm, 50 x4 - Save 2
17: Ca 7 & Arm spent; ca9 - Save 5
8: seven fresh

Save & bank 8
66 4/15/2021 8:52:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message Ca 8 spent
65 4/15/2021 8:52:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

3
4
2
1


Message from Allies:
A6 AERIAL REFIT:

17: Ca 7, 8, Arm @ +3, Ca 9 @ +4
64 4/15/2021 7:28:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Edit Supplies Allies: from 0 to 0
Germans: from 0 to 2
63 4/15/2021 7:28:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message 6G Refit

1: 1 supply - 731 fresh - save 4
5: 1 supply - 22 & 711/Art fresh
in 10 - 736 fresh - save 1
16: 1 supply - 21Pz/PAK,Flak fresh - save 3
29: 1 supply - 352/Art,916 & 726 fresh
in 19 - CA fresh - save 0
31: 1 supply - CA & 32 Flak fresh - save 3
52: 1 supply - 709/729,919 AOK7 1058 all fresh - save 1


Total 12 supplies saved, will use 10 to start day @ 1
62 4/14/2021 8:05:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message 18/16 built - day ends
61 4/14/2021 8:04:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

1
6
3
2


Message from Allies:
6A8:

18: Build 18/20 & 18/16 @ +2; last two rolls for day/weather
60 4/14/2021 6:54:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message 22 makes it to 5
59 4/14/2021 6:53:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

5


Message from Germans:
6G8
3: 22 to 4,5 - interdiction dr
58 4/13/2021 7:23:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

5
6


Message from Allies:
Yes ... you were confused. I never tried to land 4 artillery and won't now either. I was referring to the 50 art which couldn't land as part of the 11:6 vs Gold. So, will land it now.

6A7:

50 Art to 18. Day/weather DR
57 4/13/2021 7:18:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message Oh, bridge captured!!!!
56 4/13/2021 7:16:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message Ooops! I just saw that you didn't try to land the Artillery unit in Utah on your assault. I was confused by your request of 2 drs! - My mistake!!!!!
55 4/13/2021 7:13:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

6


Message from Germans:
Thanks for the clarification of the rules. One reason why I like playing against you is that you know the rules. The number of players that don't know the complete rules (including me!!!) is more that I can count. The other reason why I like playing against you is that you are a worthy opponent and you have an unique style of play (both as the Germans and Allies) that I have learned from.

So, with all this said, I guess I going to have make sure YOU following the rules. That brings up the assault on Utah. You cannot land your Artillery on a Mandatory assault. So, your Artillery is still fresh in Utah Approach.

6G6
919 attempts to capture 52-50 bridge - need a 5 or A 6
54 4/12/2021 9:56:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

5
3


Message from Allies:
Interesting set of circumstances.

First, because it is a friendly game I would accept whatever you deemed appropriate.

Second, it really wasn't an illegal move - it simply was an error in interpreting the results of a legal move. What would have been illegal would have been to accept the erroneous results.

Third, since the "5" dice roll was stated as an end of day roll it could not be accepted since by rule, the next dice roll had to be the resolution of the mandatory 7:3 assault.

I will grant you that some protocol has been established for requiring erroneous dice rolls to be carried over to the next roll, but I believe that is more of a rule of thumb for rolling an incorrect number of dice rather than for a completely different action than the one stated for the roll in the first place. As such, I believe there is certainly grounds for disregarding the roll - and that is what I would have ruled as a GM for this situation.

Fourth, you are correct that technically the rules require a "buyer beware" attitude of the defender while giving him the right of acceptance or refusal of an illegal move - provided he exercises it before the next impulse is made. However, as stated above - this was not an illegal move - rather a misread result - and as such - one that had to be corrected. It was.

Fifth, your point about illegal moves being cited or corrected now rears its ugly head in my 11:6 assault of 18 impulse where I landed all four units of the 50th XX - which was illegal as cited - since artillery cannot land as part of a mandatory assault against intact fortifications. You did not cite the error and played on - so technically, that move is legal.

Since it is only a game, I suggest that we consider the 50th Art as unlanded.

6A6:

land 3 Art; day/weather DR:
53 4/12/2021 8:57:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message Bridge not captured, 2nd time I roll a 6/2 combination
52 4/12/2021 8:57:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

6
2


Message from Germans:
Good thing this is a friendly game. I would have insist that the 1st 2 drs (you use for the SDR) should have been used for your assault dr which would have been a five, which would cause a weather change, which would have cost me 2 CPs, which mean I would have still control 51. Also, since it was an illegal move, don't I have a determination on taking the move or not?

ITS ONLY A GAME!!!!

6G6
60: AOK7 to 53,52 & attempts to capture 52-50 bridge
1st dr - interdiction
2nd dr - bridge capture attempt
51 4/11/2021 9:03:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message Much better ... Utah cleared ... at last with OVR and weather remains normal.
50 4/11/2021 9:02:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

3
4
1
6


Message from Allies:
6A5, Part 2:

I seem to have a self fulfilling death wish. In retrospect, only one die roll was called for so the second is meaningless and 4/22 survived the interdiction. Therefore, it now makes the 7:3 assault ... it can do no worse ...
49 4/11/2021 8:34:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message of course ...
48 4/11/2021 8:33:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

4
1


Message from Allies:
6A5:

weather/EOD:
47 4/11/2021 8:33:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message what a surprise - two games in a row Utah interdiction goes 3 for 3!
46 4/11/2021 8:32:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

6
1


Message from Allies:
6A5:

4/22 to 51; interdiction > 2:
45 4/11/2021 7:08:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message Nope again
44 4/11/2021 7:07:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

6
2


Message from Germans:
6G5
58: 739 to 54,52 & attempts to capture bridge if not interdicted

dr1 - interdiction
dr2 - brdige capture attempt
43 4/10/2021 7:33:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Edit Advantage Allies: from X to
Germans: from to X
42 4/10/2021 7:33:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

6
5


Message from Allies:
!@* - there is no end to my misery - 20 out of 22 adverse WC's

Reroll -
41 4/10/2021 7:32:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

2
2


Message from Allies:
6A4:

land 1 & 29 Art; weather/day DR
40 4/10/2021 7:20:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message Nope
39 4/10/2021 7:20:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

3


Message from Germans:
6G4
54: 1058 to 52 & attempts to capture 52-50 bridge - +2
38 4/9/2021 9:02:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message 6A3:

8 Arm & 50 x4 to 18 @ 11:6 - 3 Cps - KIA CA
37 4/9/2021 9:01:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

3
3
5
3


Message from Allies:
6A3:

8 Arm & 50 x4 to 18 @ 11:6
36 4/9/2021 6:50:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message 711/Art to 5
35 4/9/2021 6:50:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

3
5


Message from Germans:
731 spent in 1

711/Art to 1,6,5 - interdiction drs

34 4/9/2021 6:49:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

2
6


Message from Germans:
Please not that you had the wrong game on your last action.


6G3
A: 731 to 1,6,5 - interdiction drs
33 4/8/2021 12:56:00 PM Turn 1 Allies Message nope - zilch ... the 9th was bad mojo for me
32 4/8/2021 12:56:00 PM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

5
2
3
2


Message from Allies:
9A Aerial Refit:

Will refit all in 50 regardless so this is just to see if I can get any freebies
31 4/8/2021 9:18:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message Seizure fails
30 4/8/2021 9:18:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 1

1


Message from Allies:
6A2, Part 2:

Ca9 to 17 @ 6:6 - whoopee! OVR - seize 17/18
29 4/8/2021 9:16:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

5
4
3
1


Message from Allies:
6A2:

Ca9 to 17 @ 6:6
28 4/8/2021 6:27:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message 17-16 bridge down
27 4/8/2021 6:26:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

2
5


Message from Germans:
6G2
17: Bridge demo attempts
17-18 +4 dr1
17-16 +5 dr2
26 4/7/2021 10:34:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message Ca8 D1
25 4/7/2021 10:34:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

4
3
2
6


Message from Allies:
6A1:

Ca8 to 17 @ 6:6
24 4/7/2021 7:40:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message 18-16 & 18-20 bridges down
23 4/7/2021 7:39:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 3

1
6
2


Message from Germans:
6G1
18: bridge demo attempts
18-17 +4 dr1
18-16 +5 dr2
18-20 +5 dr3
22 4/6/2021 7:18:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message Ca Arm D1
21 4/6/2021 7:17:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

2
2
6
3


Message from Allies:
6A0:

Ca Arm to 17 @ 7:6
20 4/6/2021 6:58:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message On Omaha, CA D1, 726/916 & 352/Art all spent & all retreat to 29.
On Sword, CA D1, 736 to 10

6G0
10: 21/PAK,Flak to 16 -

Almost activated 16 to blow the 2 bridges - should have tried!!!!!
19 4/5/2021 9:35:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message Landings, Part 1:

Gold @ 5:6 - 56X D1
Juno @ 6:6 - Ca 7 D1 - the landing rolls are the ones that count
Omaha @ 14: 9 - 6 CPs
Sword @ 13:8 - 2 CPs ...

Like I said ... the bombardment rolls help but the Landing rolls are the important ones ... you won 4 out of 5 so if you want to change sides I'd take the offer.
18 4/5/2021 9:33:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

3
1
4
3


Message from Allies:
Landings, Part 4:

Gold @ 5:6 - 56X D1
Juno @ 6:6 - Ca 7 D1 - the landing rolls are the ones that count
Omaha @ 14: 9 - 6 CPs
Sword @ 13:8 -
17 4/5/2021 9:32:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

6
2
4
3


Message from Allies:
Landings, Part 1:

Gold @ 5:6 - 56X D1
Juno @ 6:6 - Ca 7 D1 - the landing rolls are the ones that count
Omaha @ 14: 9 -
16 4/5/2021 9:30:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

6
1
4
6


Message from Allies:
Landings, Part 1:

Gold @ 5:6 - 56X D1
Juno @ 6:6 -
15 4/5/2021 9:30:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

2
2
3
2


Message from Allies:
Landings, Part 1:

Gold @ 5:6 -
14 4/5/2021 9:29:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message You'd understand if you saw my last game as Allies - 3 out of 3 D1 interdictions vs Utah ... needless to say Allies never got off Utah Beach.
13 4/5/2021 7:54:00 AM Turn 1 Germans Message 916 spent in 30
32 Flak spent in 29

I can't believe u are complaining (again!!!) about the interdiction dr on Utah compare to what the other drs were.
I'll switch sides with u if you want!!
12 4/2/2021 11:09:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message Not this again ... !

Interdiction Phase (only Utah has shots)

vs Utah: 4/8 & 12 > 2 - both units D1
vs Omaha: 16, 18, 26, 115, 116, 2R, 5R
vs Gold: 56X
vs Juno: Ca7
vs Sword: 27 Arm, 8, 9, 185, 1 & 4 ss

Specify losses on 30 & 31 plus Primary Defender on Omaha before landings
11 4/2/2021 11:06:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 2

1
1


Message from Allies:
Interdiction Phase (only Utah has shots)

vs Utah: 4/8 & 12 > 2
vs Omaha: 16, 18, 26, 115, 116, 2R, 5R
vs Gold: 56X
vs Juno: Ca7
vs Sword: 27 Arm, 8, 9, 185, 1 & 4 ss
10 4/2/2021 11:03:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Message Air Bombardment Phase vs 19 & 31 - again CA is Primary Target

2 TAC vs 19 @ 5:1 - CA spent
IX AF vs 31 @ 5:2 - 4 APs

9 4/2/2021 11:03:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

6
3
5
3


Message from Allies:
Air Bombardment Phase vs 19 & 31 - again CA is Primary Target

2 TAC vs 19 @ 5:1 - CA spent
IX AF vs 31 @ 5:2 -
8 4/2/2021 11:02:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

1
4
3
3


Message from Allies:
Naval Bombardment Phase: CA Always Primary Target where applicable

Sword - 8:4 - both spent
Juno - 8:4 - CA spent
Gold - 8:4 - CA spent
Omaha - 8:4 - 5 APs
Utah - 8:3 - 1/919 spent

Air Bombardment Phase vs 19 & 31

2 TAC vs 19 @ 5:1 -
7 4/2/2021 11:00:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

5
6
6
3


Message from Allies:
Naval Bombardment Phase: CA Always Primary Target where applicable

Sword - 8:4 - both spent
Juno - 8:4 - CA spent
Gold - 8:4 - CA spent
Omaha - 8:4 - 5 APs
Utah - 8:3 -
6 4/2/2021 10:59:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

4
3
3
3


Message from Allies:
Naval Bombardment Phase: CA Always Primary Target where applicable

Sword - 8:4 - both spent
Juno - 8:4 - CA spent
Gold - 8:4 - CA spent
Omaha - 8:4 -
5 4/2/2021 10:58:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

2
4
1
5


Message from Allies:


Naval Bombardment Phase: CA Always Primary Target where applicable

Sword - 8:4 - both spent
Juno - 8:4 - CA spent
Gold - 8:4 -

4 4/2/2021 10:58:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

1
2
2
2


Message from Allies:


Naval Bombardment Phase: CA Always Primary Target where applicable

Sword - 8:4 - both spent
Juno - 8:4 -

3 4/2/2021 10:57:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

2
6
3
1


Message from Allies:
Aerial Phase:
507 -49/50
501 - 44/50
502 - 52/50
505 - 51/50
6/3 vs 7 @ 3:3 - OVR

Naval Bombardment Phase: CA Always Primary Target where applicable

Sword - 8:4 -
2 4/2/2021 10:55:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Die roll request Request: 6-sided die x 4

5
5
4
2


Message from Allies:
Here we go again. Suggest you delete our old "Don/Steve" game. As you are the owner I cannot delete it.

Aerial Phase:
507 -49/50
501 - 44/50
502 - 52/50
505 - 51/50
6/3 vs 7 @ 3:3
1 4/2/2021 10:52:00 AM Turn 1 Allies Edit Advantage Allies: from to X
Germans: from to

Next 100 entries

Copyright 2005 Warhorse Simulations